Columbia >Food & Dining > Schiano's Italian Eatery
10132 Two Notch Rd, Columbia, SC | Directions 2922334.115975 -80.885772
Mon - Thu, 11am - 10pm; Fri - Sat, 11am - 11pm; Sun, 11am - 10pm
Neighborhoods: Northeast Arcadia Lakes, Northeast
Women Steer Clear, If You Dont Want To Be Disrespected – Don't send your wife/girlfriend there alone. The men there love to hit on women even if they are married. I will not be going back for any reason. They need to hire people with the proper respect, course I guess you can not expect much from people these days.
Steer clear if you do not want to have your wife/girlfriend disrespected.
Back In the Day – I went to Spring Valley High ('85) and used to eat Schiano's regularly. I knew I liked it (especially plain cheese), but when I married a girl from the Bronx and tasted real NY pizza, I knew it was good. When family comes down, we always like to get a pie.
Schiano's Italian Eatery – I had delivery. Came within a half hour. And the pizza was the best south of Phili!!! yumm
Good pizza – I am a big pizza fan, and I thought the pizza here was pretty good. When my brother was visiting, he said it was the best pizza he had ever had. I just wish that you could add pineapple to the pizza, like you can with all of the pizza chains.
best pie in cola area – best pizza pie around this area, and for a southern girl brought up in jersey, trust me I know real pizza.
the decor could use some work, mainly the booth seating needs to be recovered, but there is nothing wrong with the food, it's great and could be served anywhere in NY/NJ.
From a yankee that knows good pizza – I stumbled accross this page, and I usually don't write reviews, but I was disapointed with the bad reviews about my favorite pizza place. The pizza is great, take it from a native of NY, born and raised. This is the best pizza you will get down here in Columbia SC. Dont let someone's experience with bad waiter ruin an oppertunity to eat a great pizza!
Good pizza, bad place – Ok so the pizza is good especially if you just want one or two slices. I would not get anything else there though. They know what they are doing with pizza but they really need to remodel the place or at least clean it up a bit. :/
Not the best – First off, I love family owned places and I was excited to try Schiano's out. It started off bad with a dirty booth and way too much sugar in the tea and dressing on the salad. Server never asked why I didn't finish either nor why I wanted water instead of the tea, for that matter the server never returned after dropping the plates. The chicken parm was delivered burned and again, she never asked how it was. I had it replaced with pasta and sauce by the front end manager. The replacement took way too long, my companion was finished before my plate even arrived. The server never replaced my silverware so I was left sitting without anyway to eat. Finally my companion found a pile of silverware rolled up and they were dirty.
Not a good first impression. Would I return? No, take your business some place that trains the waitstaff and kitchen help.
Best NY style pizza in Northeast Columbia! – One of the best new york style pizza shops in the area, the owners from NJ he knows what hes doin with a pie!
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Schiano's Italian Eatery on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.